Welcome to Mama's Pizza Shelby
At Mama's Pizza Shelby, we believe in bringing authentic Italian flavors to the heart of Shelby, Ohio. Nestled on Mansfield Avenue, our family-run restaurant has garnered a loyal following for its comforting and delicious offerings. From our indulgent Foldovers and acclaimed bone-in wings to our crowd-favorite Philly steak pizza, each dish reflects our commitment to quality and taste. Our friendly staff, like Tim and Ashley, ensure every customer feels welcome and valued. Whether dining in or taking out, we strive to deliver not just a meal, but a vibrant experience that keeps our patrons coming back for more. Come visit us!
-
40 Mansfield Ave, Shelby, OH 44875 Hotline: (419) 342-7777
Welcome to Mama's Pizza Shelby, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Shelby, Ohio, at 40 Mansfield Ave. This charming eatery has gained a reputation for serving up mouthwatering Italian cuisine, primarily focusing on their savory pizzas and delectable foldovers that keep both locals and visitors coming back for more.
As you step into Mama's Pizza Shelby, you're met with a warm, inviting atmosphere that suggests comfort and community. This isn't just a pizza place; it’s a cozy corner where flavor meets affection, and it’s clear that each dish is made with care. Whether you're a die-hard pizza fan or in the mood for something unique, the menu here has something to satisfy every craving.
- Pizzas: The standout is undoubtedly their Philly Steak Pizza, described by satisfied customers as "loaded with meat" and deliciously filling. It’s a testament to Mama’s commitment to quality and taste.
- Foldovers: If you haven't tried the foldovers, you’re missing out! With rave reviews from patrons who claim they serve the best foldovers they've ever had, options like the Bacon Cheeseburger Foldover and the Meat Lovers Melt are definitely worth a taste.
- Sides: Complement your meal with their crispy onion rings or the newly added Wisconsin cheese curds! Many customers have noted the sides as a perfect addition to the main dishes, enhancing the overall experience.
- Customer Service: The staff at Mama's Pizza Shelby is renowned for their friendliness and efficiency, creating a welcoming environment that feels like home. Many diners appreciate how they go above and beyond, ensuring that each order is prepared to perfection and ready on time.
The heartwarming reviews highlight not just the food, but the sense of community fostered by staff like Ashley and Tim, who leave a lasting impression on customers. This friendly service is as integral to the Mama’s experience as the delicious menu offerings.
In a world filled with pizza and takeout options, Mama's Pizza Shelby sets itself apart with its engaging atmosphere, diverse menu, and commitment to exceptional service. A dining experience here is not just about satisfying hunger; it’s about savoring every bite and celebrating the joy of great food and great company.
So next time you're in Shelby, or even if you're just passing through, make sure to swing by Mama's Pizza Shelby. You won't leave disappointed — just stuffed and eager to come back for more!
This is a nice little holeinthewall pizza shop. The food is good. My wife and I enjoyed the Philly steak pizza. It was loaded with meat and was more than we could finish in one sitting.
Foldovers are the best Ive ever had anywhere. The club Foldover is the best. Pizza and wings and everything else are all good. Highly recommend them. We try to get food here every time we are in town. Customer service is always good, they are always nice here.
Ashley..is awesome. Always very pleasant on the phone when I know they are under pressure for the last minute calls. Im always satisfied with my order. Awesome onion rings and foldovers to die for...keep up the good work. You guys rock it out!
Their food is always awesome bonein wings are better FYI. We probably order once every two weeks and everyone is very friendly and they deliver to us in a timely manner, even when theyre busy. ...
Super friendly service. The last two times we ordered, the lady we picked up from was super friendly and helpful. Food was great. My daughters really enjoyed the grilled chicken ranch subs. Both times ordered were ready before our estimated pick up time.
This is the best place ever!!!!! Tim by far the best employee I have ever met!! He was just the sweetest guy. I was having a really bad day and I just wanted to go home and bury my head in my blankets. I had to get dinner for my kids. I ...
Not only does this place have amazing pizza and sides but their chef salad is my favorite! Its huge and everything is cut up into bite sized pieces.
This place used to be just okay, but now its so great! Im not sure what changed, but wow the food is so much tastier! Theyve also added new menu items, I cant get enough of the Wisconsin cheese curds and the funnel fries! Ordering ...